In Defence of Liberty

Driven by data; ridden with liberty.

Party Election Broadcasts II: Liberal Democrats, UKIP

Apologies, I am somewhat behind. (Source: BBC)

Apologies, I am somewhat behind. (Source: BBC)

Liberal Democrats

(Video: Liberal Democrats)

On the second exit, go down Metaphor Way. Led by a sat-nav, the Liberal Democrats may have reached their final destination in this party election broadcast. The film’s theme is that the Liberal Democrats are a moderating influence on the two major parties, so voters should ‘Look Left, Look Right, then Cross’ Liberal Democrats.

After the sat-nav says ‘turn right’, the voice-over replies:

The Tories only care about the wealthy. The rich are getting richer, whilst services like the NHS suffer.

The National Health Service budget, in England, was protected by the coalition government. In the UK, health spending has increased in real terms over the course of the parliament. However, these increases have been neither large nor consistent.

The NHS spending has increased in this parliament. (Source: Institute for Fiscal Studies)

The NHS spending has increased in this parliament. (Source: Institute for Fiscal Studies)

Conservatives would contest that they “only care about the wealthy”. Furthermore, it is strange to claim that the NHS has suffered under this government, of which the Liberal Democrats were part.

After being asked to ‘turn left’, the voice-over says:

To what? A Labour government who’ll ruin my future job security.

It is not really explained how a Labour government would reduce our job security to rubble and ruination. The insinuation is left to the viewer.
“At the crossroads, it is up to you.” Whether this broadcast will drive any votes is yet to be seen.

UKIP

(Video: ukipmedia)

Recalling the comedy series Monty Python, UKIP leader Nigel Farage states to the camera: “And now for something completely different.” What follows is a typical election broadcast, with the party leader telling us about their values and vision. Mr Farage recites:

The reason we call it the People’s Army is because it’s ordinary folks against the political class.

The film suggests that the UK Independence Party are “closer to the kind of conversations that go on in households up and down this country every single day”. In this address, Mr Farage asserts:

The rich are getting richer, the poor are getting poorer.

It is a common claim, possibly due to its rhetorical symmetry. Looking between 2007-08 and 2012-13, data from the Office for National Statistics suggests otherwise:

The fall in income has been largest for the richest fifth of households (5.2%). In contrast, after accounting for inflation and household composition, the average income for the poorest fifth has grown over this period (3.5%).

The reduction of taxation on low incomes is welcome. UKIP will hope to grow their support at the General Election.

Advertisements

3 comments on “Party Election Broadcasts II: Liberal Democrats, UKIP

  1. richmalpass
    April 14, 2015

    It is a shame that the political landscape seems to have shifted from vision to cheap sniping and points scoring. It’s also depressing that UKIP are still involved at all:

    http://lovelanguageloveliterature.com/2015/04/14/ukip-destroying-the-meaning-of-british/

    • Anthony Masters
      April 14, 2015

      I certainly agree with your article about how the concepts of national identity are not uniform, and rarely shared across a nation.

      I often find the vicissitudes of modern politics, with all of its personal attacks and insinuations, to be quite tiring.

      • richmalpass
        April 14, 2015

        It really is tiring. It seems a shame that the parties on the margin are the ones who seem interested in promoting their ideals and engaging in proper political persuasion and campaigning, and yet their most realistic hopes of parliament are on the coat-tails of Labour or the Tories.

Comments are closed.

Information

This entry was posted on April 14, 2015 by in National Politics and tagged , , , , .
%d bloggers like this: